Ooey Gooey Butter Cake

Jul 22, 2019 | Food, Sweets

This is a re-post:  Easter is this Sunday and I’m sure everyone is either eating out or making something at home and this Ooey Gooey Butter Cake is the perfect dessert to make!  Sometimes when we have dinner plans, I still like to have a dessert made for us when we get home.  I also like waking up to a breakfast of coffee and dessert :-).  This cake is so simply to make so I wanted to pass it along again.  I’ve included more links along with this updated post and the history of Ooey Gooey Butter Cake!

St. Louis, MO is known for their Ooey Gooey Butter Cake which was made by accident and has became a staple in the city.  We spend time there (about 6 months out of the year) and always make a trip to our favorite bakery (McArthur’s Bakery) for some ooey gooey sweetness.  We are back home now and with Thanksgiving being tomorrow, I offered to make a dessert to bring to my sister’s house for Thanksgiving dinner.  I told everyone it’s a surprise because I know they LOVE this cake!  When I take the lid off this dessert, I know everyone will be smiling for sure!

History of the Ooey Gooey Butter Cake

Gooey Butter Cake History and Recipe

The cake was supposedly first made by accident in the 1930s by a St. Louis-area German American baker who was trying to make regular cake batter but reversed the proportions of butter and flour. John Hoffman was the owner of the bakery where the mistake was made.

This story alleges that the baker got the butter smears mixed up, resulting in a delicious accident. The mistake was made during the Great Depression, so supplies for ingredients were low and they had no intention to waste food. So, they sold this new cake as it was.

Want more sweet goodness, check out my recipes here!  I hope you enjoy them and can use one for your Easter dinner!  We are eating at the Grand Concourse this year and can’t wait to have their amazing Easter buffet.

Ooey Gooey Sugar Cookie Stack

Celebrating with your fur baby?  Make them these Banana Bread Pup Cakes!

Looking for Easter table inspiration?  Check out my latest Easter Bunny table!

Ingredients:

  • 1 and ½ cup of melted butter – I used Land O’ Lakes Salted Butter Sticks
  • 1 box of yellow cake mix – I used Betty Crocker
  • 3 eggs – I used Organic Farm Raised
  • 1 8 oz package of Philadelphia cream cheese
  • 1 teaspoon of pure Vanilla extract – I used Watkins Original Gourmet.  You could probably get away with using 1/2 teaspoon but I like a vanilla flavor.  You can also try almond extract as well.  
  • 4 cups of confection sugar – I call it powdered sugar 🙂

Step One:  Mix together yellow cake mix, 1 egg and melted butter into batter and spread evenly into a 9 x 13 inch pan.  Don’t get worried when the batter consistency is thicker than a normal cake batter.  

Note:  Make sure you grease the bottom of the pan.  I used PAM Butter spray but you can use either butter or Crisco to wipe down your pan with.

Step Two:  Mix together  remaining 2 eggs, cream cheese, vanilla, and powdered sugar until creamy and the cream cheese is blended without chunks.  Pour over batter until level.  

Bake at 350 degrees for approximately 35-45 minutes.  With my oven, my cake took 45 minutes.  You will know when the top layer starts to get brown that it’s pretty much done and ready to take out.  

Cover top with powdered sugar.  You can wait until it’s cool but I chose to add the sugar right out of the oven!  I couldn’t wait!

Add a side of Starbuck’s Columbian coffee and you’ve got yourself a nice little treat!  

​Don’t forget to share this post with friends!  Photography by Thomas Domitrovich

You Might Also Like

Apple Butter Cookies

Apple Butter Cookies

Happy Wednesday everyone!  Baking these Apple Butter Cookies brought all the falls feels!  Browned butter, apple butter, nutmeg, cinnamon, all-spice, brown sugar, maple syrup!  What better way to enjoy a rainy day than to bake these cookies…gooey with large chunks of...

Lemon Butter Garlic Sauce

Lemon Butter Garlic Sauce

Happy Wednesday everyone!  This Lemon Butter Garlic Sauce packs a punch!  It tastes exactly how it sounds with strong lemon, butter, and garlic flavors and smells incredible.  Mr. TAL kept asking what I was making and I couldn’t wait to surprise him.  I tossed in some...

Banana Foster

Banana Foster

Happy Wednesday everyone!  Are you in the mood for something deliciously sweet?  This banana foster is the perfect topping for a French Vanilla ice cream sundae.  Bananas coated in a rich, buttery, syrupy sweet mixture is the perfect topping for sundaes and French...

Handmade Tater Tots

Handmade Tater Tots

Happy Wednesday everyone!  I literally just made these Handmade Tater Tots for Mr. TAL and they were delicious.  I had a totally different post going out today which was a Bananas Foster recipe but I’ll save that for next week!  Shredded potatoes, cream cheese, extra...

Baked Gnocchi With Pomodoro Sauce

Baked Gnocchi With Pomodoro Sauce

Happy Wednesday everyone!  This Baked Gnocchi With Pomodoro Sauce is incredibly easy to make with loads of flavor!  This simple tomato sauce gets tons of flavor from herbs sautéed in olive oil with pillows of potato gnocchi and topped with mozzarella cheese!  Mix in a...

Bacon Wrapped Puff Pastry Twists

Bacon Wrapped Puff Pastry Twists

Happy Wednesday everyone!  These Bacon Wrapped Puff Pastry Twists are incredible!  Puff Pastry intertwined with thick salty bacon strips, smothered in egg, cheese, cayenne pepper, nutmeg, garlic powder, then coated with more egg, cheese, and brown sugar.  These twists...

What Do You Think? Let Us Know!

2 Comments

  1. Barbara Bolduc

    That cake does look yummy 😋and easy to make. It’s definitely on my to do list. Thanks for the recipe Bobbi Jo and Happy Easter!! 🐰❤️🥰

    Reply
    • Two Adorable Labs

      Great! Let me know what you think! We loved it when we tried it in St. Louis so I had to make it. Thomas gave it a thumb’s up :-). Hope you had a great Easter!

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.